My Favorite 2nd Basemen
of All-Time
This list includes more eras and than my first basemen list of June 28. I learned that few 2nd basemen in history have gone on to excel past age 34 - Lou Whitaker, of the Tigers - being a prime exception.
1. Joe Morgan, Reds: A class guy and fantastic player, I also loved him in his prime as an announcer on ESPN Sunday night baseball alongside Jon Miller. He had one of the most unique batting styles ever, but I can't find any video of it to share.
2. Ryne Sandberg, Cubs: He just beats out Nos. 4 and 5. As classy as Morgan, Sandberg was amazingly consistent. He deserved the managerial spot vacated by Lou Piniella last year.
3. Rogers Hornsby, Cardinals: He was the Ty Cobb of the National League in the 1910s and '20s. During one five-year stretch (1921-25) he batted .402!
4. Rod Carew, Twins: My first American League player! Almost the opposite of my favorite 1st basemen. Carew was so cool, and his slap-hitting style reminded me of Cobb.
5. Jackie Robinson, Dodgers: Maybe he should be up higher, but I never saw him play and I haven't read as much about him. He deserves all the accolades he's received over the years, but he's just No. 5 for me.
6. Napolean "Nap" LaJoie, Indians: His name is classic enough, but he also had a .339 career batting average and fought tooth-and-nail (not quite literally) with Cobb for batting titles.
7. Roberto Alomar, Blue Jays: Another very consistent and strong 2nd baseman who could do it all.
8. Lou Whitaker, Tigers: He moved up a couple of notches after I learned about his durability.
9. Jeff Kent, Giants: I've heard he wasn't liked by everyone, but you had to like his determination and abilities.
10. Craig Biggio, Astros: Along with Jeff Bagwell at 1st, he was a formidable offensive threat. (Honestly, I just checked and noticed that Bagwell was my No. 10 1st baseman!)
Robby Thompson was always one of my favorite Giants' second basemen.
ReplyDeleteHe played 11 seasons, all for San Francisco, and formed part of a great infield with Will Clark, Matt Williams and Jose Uribe.
I thought about you as I listed McCovey and Kent. The Giants definitely have had a great history.
ReplyDeleteI can't believe Gumby Gantner didn't make your list, but you were probably pulling for the Red Sox over the Brewers even then.
ReplyDelete